Review of umpiring fiascos in international Cricket matches by Vineet Garg
Why Indian Umpires are not taken in elite panel when the present elite panel is performing so disastrously
Just watch this video. This video ridicules the incident but it is totally wrong.
In the latest one-day match between India and Sri Lanka, a very bizarre incident happened. Ashwin ran out Lankan player Thirimanne in accordance with the newly made law. Almost the whole Cricket world thinks that it was a shameful act by Ashwin but he was following the newly-made rule. Ashwin had already warned the batsman in the previous overs.
The Indian team withdrew the run-out after Paul Reiffel consulted with Billy Bowden, which was against the laws of umpiring.
The umpiring standards were below any level. The question of Indian umpires not being included in the elite panel becomes imperative here. Do the authorities think that Indian umpires would perform even below these standards? Why they are not given the chance of being in the elite panel?
Vineet Garg talks about this issue and also about the bowling coach that the Indian team is about to have.
We present a telephonic conversation with Vineet.
Vineet Sir
I am also agree that the umpiring standards of ongoing Triangular Series is below any level. The role of Umpiring in the match against Australia on dated 26.02.2012 was also biased. Decision regarding Run out of Hussey and Sachin was unfortunate in view of spirit/law of the game. The decision regarding Indian umpires not being included in the elite panel is also wrong in these situation. India has also produced Very good Umpire like Venky. So Indian umpires also deserve in the elite panel especially in the present scenario.
Vineet sir
Thanks for your comment. Please write more about this topic to me on nkumar.india@yahoo.com. I will wait for you………………..
NARESH
Hi !Vinit sir,sbse pahle mai apko tahe dil se pranam krta hu.Sir apki commentry me na jane kya jadu hai jo mujhe ‘mantramugdh’ kar deti hai aur mai chah kar bhi apne apko rok nhi pata hu.Sir ap mere ideal hai aur in future mujhe vishvas hai ki ap mujhe kbhi bhi apne Ashirvad se vanchit nhi krenge ,sir mere pure parivar ki hardik abhilasha hai ki apse ekbar bat kre aur apne apko dhany kre.I LOVE U SIR-my mob no is( 08726272626)
Mr vineet garg sahib, (finest & knowledgible commentator that India have every produced) Yes i am fully agree with ur comments regarding to the umpiring fiscos.These r newly made laws by ICC but the umpires failed to apply in CB SERIES & every decision went against india.The decisions like runout of Tharamine’s,David hussy’s ,Tendulkar’s .Any unnecessary delibrate action is totally prohibited.when Surash raina threw the ball towards stumps Inzimam came into way & delibrately stoped the throw frm Surash Raina in ODI,the Inzimam was given out.Indians r fully aware about the new rules.I think Indian empires should be a part of elite pannel.Thanks may u lve long(UR BIG SUPPORTER SHEERAZ AHMAD FROM KASHMIR.
Sir ki najar stadiyam ke hr kone pr rahti he hrchij pr sir kamal ke he